Musculoskeletal system disorders in competitive ballroom dancers: correction methods based on elliptic-round triple movements

Фотографии: 

ˑ: 

E.R. Yashina
T.F. Abramova
V.I. Boytsov
N.I. Kochetkova
R.V. Malkin
T.M. Nikitina
All-Russian Research Institute of Physical Culture and Sport, Moscow

Keywords: corrective methods, musculoskeletal system (MSS), elliptical-round movement of footplate, highly-skilled athletes, competitive ballroom dances.

Background. Long-term studies of the musculoskeletal system (MSS) specifics in athletes specialized in different sport disciplines have demonstrated that sport-specific spatial orientation malfunctions and trunk disorders are caused by multisided evolution, i.e. by intensification of the evolutionary predisposed and typical functional asymmetry aggravated by high-intensity physical activity, gender dimorphism (skews of pelvis and lumbar lordosis) and the main motor stereotype formed by prolonged, focused and intense training process. Long-term athletic career is known to form specific muscular ensembles due to adaptive body changes that, when accumulated, result in stable distortions in the coupled muscles and agonist-antagonist muscles that may be aggravated by other body malfunctions with the situational functional shifts being transformed to stable disorders in the MSS segments associated with pain syndromes. This is the reason for the high priority being given to the measures intended to prevent the negative processes and optimize the functionality of the athletes’ MSS in the athletic training process.

The commonly applicable MSS functionality optimization methods are quite efficient and beneficial in solving a variety of specific and general therapeutic problems, and in addition they may be applied for preventive purposes too. There are also a few constraining requirements for these methods, including: subjective difficulties and barriers in performing the relevant practices; need for due laboratory conditions and highly-skilled service professionals; and strict compliance with every detail of the key movement patterns in case of athletic practices.

The main aspect of a corrective action to harmonize the overall neuromuscular balance of a body is based on the human body being assumed as an integrated myofascial system. Practical modern technologies geared to implement this approach were combined in a new corrective IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system (France-made) that is designed on a basic principle of a biomechanical movable unstable platform. The platform movements follow the pattern of an ascending conic spiral being dominated by elliptical-round triple movements to secure simultaneous interactions in every muscle group controlling movements of the relevant joints through concentric, eccentric and pliometric movements; and simulate the physiologically balanced movements of vertebrae in relation to the intervertebral disks in a series of spiral movements. The system secures dynamic postural changes being achieved through segmented practices for the key muscular groups; regulates the degree of neuromuscular stimulation and multisensory action on the proprioception using the biological feedback; and ensures due versatility of the movement patterns thereby helping recreate the strength and tone of the weakened muscles and balance the hypersthenia. The system includes a central immovable column with a fixed screen, immovable and moving handles and movable platform with foothold sensors (see Figure 1). The IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system is supported by the application software that offers a wide range of testing and rehabilitating programmed practices with motor-visual control and the relevant biological feedback; and with self-control of the imposed optimal stereotype of the preset movement sequence. Different conditions related to surgical removal of hernia, spondylosis, arthrosis and varicosity of lower limb veins are not among the contraindications for the practices. Main contraindications include: 3rd degree hypertension, acute somatic diseases, acute arthrosis and humeroscapular periarthritis.

Figure 1. Kinesiotherapeutic IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system

Objective of the study was to test corrective efficiency of the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system in athletic practices to prevent postural disorders and injuries.

Methods and structure of the study. The study was performed at Russian Research Institute of Physical Education and Sport (Moscow). Subject to the study were 18 male competitive ballroom dancers (from the competitive dancing clubs “Novy vek" ("New Age”), "Akademiya" “Academy” and "Russkiy klub" (“Russian Club”) of 16-26 years of age qualified from Class I Athletes to Masters of Sport and having formal competitive track records of 3 to 15 years. Initial and final tests were performed prior to and after the experiment under the study that included the morphological, optical-tomography and stabilometric (postural balance control) tests. Following the initial tests, the subjects were trained using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system (6 times in total, 2 times per week, 25-minutes-long training sessions) and thereafter were again tested a month later. To attain the study objectives, the following methods were applied:

– Anthropometrics to obtain data on body dimensions, limb circumferences and skinfold thickness followed by calculations of muscular and fat components using standard anthropometric methodologies.

– Optical tomography using a “Computerized optical unobtrusive tomograph to diagnose spinal deformations” (TODP), with the following data being generated: qualitative and quantitative spatial positions and forms of the key body segments (shoulders, blades, pelvis, spinal axis) in the frontal (distortions, scoliotic deviations), horizontal (rotation) and sagittal (physiological bents in the thoracic and lumbar spine sections) planes; integral expressivity of the postural disorders and body form in the sagittal, frontal and horizontal planes; overall and plane-specific deviation indices (DI); occurrence rates of the local deviations in the spatial positions of the key body segments in three planes. Rated deviation degrees for the spatial positions and forms of the key body segments versus the norm, including: subnormal that means insignificant deviations; 1st degree meaning modest deviations; 2nd degree meaning expressed deviations due to the MSS pathologies; and the 3rd degree meaning significant deviations and serous MSS disorders. Accounted under the study were only the 1-3 degrees;

– Stabilometric tests were performed using the Stabilan-01 Computerized Stabiloanalyzer System with a biological feedback capacity. Standard test conditions implied the athletes standing on the platform barefooted in a “European” stand (heels tight, tips apart at 30°) as a standard stand subject to the relevant duly developed and approved regulatory stabilometric indices. The subject’s upright postural control ability was tested using the Romberg test with the postural control profile being recorded in two modes: eyes-open (with a visual stimulation by intermittent coloured rounds) and eyes-closed (with audio stimulation by tones). The tests generated a set of statokynetic stability rates (speed and square of the Aggregate Pressure Centre (APC); shift and dispersion of the oscillations by the coordinate axes; average direction of the oscillations; and the postural control function quality (PCFC); plus the contributions of the proprioceptive (eyes-closed) and visual (eyes-open) components to the postural control (with the Romberg ratio being applied as a relation of the eyes-open APC to the eyes-closed APC);

Practices using the biomechanical movable platform of the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system (see Figure 1). The athletes performed a set of 5 main exercises (see Figure 2). The first exercise is designed to stretch the back muscles: oblique and dentate muscles, broadest muscle of back, intercostal muscle, musculus iliopsoas and rectus muscle of stomach; the exercise takes 2 minutes in total, 1 minute in the left stand and 1 minute in the right stand, with the platform rotation being changed every 30 seconds (see Figure 2, upper left picture). The second exercise is designed to practice balance on the rotating platform for 5 minutes with the moving handles being actively pulled; initial stand: right foot in front, left behind, right hand pulls the moving handle in front of the body at an angle of around 30 degrees to the left, and the left hand pulls moving handle behind the body at an angle of around 30 degrees, with the hands being changed every 5 seconds; in 150 seconds, the stand is changed to the left foot in front, right foot behind (see Figure 2, upper right picture); the exercise is designed to activate musculus pectoralis major, broadest muscle of the back, musculus trapezius, musculus rhomboidalis, deep layers of the back extensor muscles, musculus iliopsoas, broad femoral fascia, musculus gluteus and musculus piriformis. The third exercise: initial stand: feet are shoulders-wide, right hand pulls the moving handle along the back, and relaxed left hand is kept aside; body position is changed every 5 seconds; the platform rotation is changed every 30 seconds; the exercise lasts for 5 minutes in total, and it is designed to train the ligaments and tendons with a special emphasis on the upper limbs, broadest muscle, musculus rhomboidalis, musculus supraspinatus and musculus infraspinatus with the lower limb muscles being activated at moments (see Figure 2, middle left picture). The fourth exercise: initial stand: right foot in front, left behind, the both hands actively pull up the moving handles for 5 seconds; the exercise takes 6 minutes in total, with the platform rotation being changed every 30 seconds and the feet positions changed every minute; the exercise is designed to train musculus deltoideus, musculus trapezius (the upper and middle bundles), long extensor muscles of trunk and the lower limb muscles (see Figure 2, the middle right picture). The fifth exercise: initial stand: feet are shoulders-wide, arms are stretched up, right side is pulled up for 10 seconds, then the left side is pulled up for 10 seconds; the exercise takes 1 minute in total and is designed to stretch muscles of back (see Figure 2, the lower picture);

– Mathematical descriptive statistics methods [3].

Figure 2. Exercises using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system

Study results and discussion. Comparative analysis of the initial test data versus final test data of the male competitive ballroom dancers (Standard and Latin) made it possible to rate the efficiency of the above practices on the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system (see Tables 1-5).

Upon completion of the practical course, the final tests showed a significant increase of the muscular mass and decrease of the fat mass, with mostly notable significant growth of the muscular mass in the forearm and thigh; and the skinfold thicknesses on the triceps, forearm, stomach and thigh were found to reduce with no changes in the body mass (Table 1).

Table 1. Morphological data variations in the male competitive ballroom dancers trained using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system

Measurements

 

Prior to practices

After practices

Difference*

Student t-criterion for related samples

σ

σ

Body height, cm

180,4

4,02

181,4

4,02

+1,00

-

Body mass, kg

69,5

4,37

69,6

4,45

+0,1

-

Muscular mass, kg

36,4

2,14

37,3

1,99

+0,9

-4,52*

Muscular mass, %

52,3

1,37

53,5

1,44

+1,2

-5,50*

Fat mass, kg

7,0

0,59

6,5

0,62

-0,5

4,21*

Fat mass, %

10,1

0,67

9,4

0,4 4

-0,7

4,43*

Fat-free shoulder radius, cm

4,24

0,18

4,29

0,16

+0,05

-

Fat-free forearm radius, cm

4,00

0,11

4,04

0,11

+0,04

-3,28*

Fat-free thigh radius, cm

8,43

0,29

8,52

0,30

+0,09

-3,16*

Fat-free shin radius, cm

5,61

0,38

5,69

0,37

+0,08

-

Skinfold thickness on back, mm

7,6

1,40

7,3

0,57

-0,3

-

Skinfold thickness on triceps, mm

7,9

1,02

7,1

0,67

-0,8

2,83*

Skinfold thickness on biceps, mm

2,8

0,39

2,5

0,41

-0,3

-

Skinfold thickness on forearm, mm

3,1

0,48

2,7

0,27

-0,4

3,29*

Skinfold thickness on chest, mm

3,6

0,35

3,5

0,50

-0,1

-

Skinfold thickness on abdomen, mm

7,6

0,75

7,1

0,69

-0,5

2,64*

Skinfold thickness on thigh, mm

6,3

0,57

5,4

0,79

-0,9

4,08*

Skinfold thickness on shin, mm

6,6

2,76

6,8

1,80

+0,2

-

Note: * significant differences

Upon completion of every practical course, the study data showed significant positive changes in the pelvis positioning and integrated deviation index (showing deviations from the physiological norms) with notable positive trends in lumbar lordosis; frontal position of pelvis; left-side deviation of the spinous process line being reduced; vertex of the thoracic kyphosis and other specific indices of disorders being optimized. The positive postural changes were verified by the positive variations in the occurrence rates of the trunk and pelvis positional deviations (see Tables 3 and 4).

Table 2. Variations in the trunk/ pelvis spatial positioning rates in the male competitive ballroom dancers trained using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system: data prior to and after the corrective practices, %

Measurements

 

Prior to

After

Difference*

Student t-criterion for related samples

σ

σ

Distortion of pelvis girdle, degrees

-2,06

2,85

-1,74

2,12

-1,06

-

Trunk bending angle, degrees

0,90

0,76

0,36

1,35

+0,17

-

Skew of pelvic girdle, degrees

-0,99

0,99

-0,81

0,67

-0,11

-

Trunk skew angle, degrees

1,53

1,49

1,81

0,91

+0,10

-

Pelvis bending angle, degrees           

-15,5

4,43

-17,1

4,38

+2,67

2,49**

Spinous process left-side deviation line, mm

-4,10

1,34

-2,61

1,43

-1,49

-

Spinous process right-side deviation line, mm

1,67

0,91

1,63

1,45

-0,04

-

Height of vertex of lumbar lordosis, mm

18,0

6,86

19,1

6,77

+1,1

-

Height of vertex of thoracic kyphosis, mm

23,8

6,19

21,6

6,11

-2,16

-

Total index of disorders, conv. units

1,02

0,25

0,87

0,14

-0,15

2,46**

Index of frontal-plane disorders, conv. units

0,99

0,19

0,83

0,23

-0,15

-

Index of horizontal-plane disorders, conv. units

0,79

0,19

0,66

0,11

-0,13

-

Index of sagittal-plane disorders, conv. units

1,15

0,56

1,01

0,38

-0,14

-

Note: * difference was calculated net of the digits of indices (+ means increase, - means decrease);

** significant differences

Table 3. Occurrence rates of the deviations from physiological norms in the spatial positions of trunk and pelvis in the male competitive ballroom dancers trained using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system: data prior to and after the corrective practices, %

Indices

Prior to practices

After practices

Right

Left

Norm

Right

Left

Norm

Frontal plane

Distortion of pelvis girdle

14,3

71,4

14,3

-

57,1

42,9

Horizontal plane

Skew in shoulder girdle

28,6

-

71,4

-

-

100

Skew in pelvis girdle

-

14,3

85,7

-

-

100

Sagittal plane

 

More

Less

 

More

Less

 

Bent of pelvis

-

28,6

71,4

-

14,3

85,7

Integral indices of disorders in the trunk form and position

Total index

-

-

57,1

-

-

85,7

Frontal plane

-

-

42,9

-

-

71,5

Horizontal plane

-

-

42,9

-

-

71,4

Sagittal plane

-

-

57,1

-

-

57,1

Postural balance data was also found indicative of positive changes after training as verified by the significant decrease of the Aggregate Pressure Centre (APC) square with an improvement trend in the postural balance control both in the eyes-open and eyes-closed modes; with the APC oscillation velocity reduction trend; and with the oscillations showing a trend to the orthogonal direction that may be interpreted as indicative of the postural control ability improvements, including, among other things, due to the muscular tonus balancing and inter-muscular group coordination being optimized (see Table 5).

Table 4. Occurrence rates of the deviations from physiological norms in the spinous process line in different spine sections in the male competitive ballroom dancers trained using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system: data prior to and after the corrective practices, %

Spinous process line deviation side

Test time

Spine sections

Total deviations

Total norm

Upper thoracic

Thoracic

Thoracic-lumbar

Lumbar

Right

Before

-

-

-

28,6

28,6

71,4

After

-

-

14,3

-

14,3

85,7

Left

Before

14,3

57,1

-

14,3

85,7

14,3

After

-

14,3

14,3

-

28,6

71,4

Table 5. Postural balance control data of in the male competitive ballroom dancers trained using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system: data prior to and after the corrective practices, %

Measurements

 

Prior to

After

Difference*

Student t-criterion for related samples

σ

σ

Eyes-open practice

 

 

 

 

 

 

CCP movement rate, mm/s

9,33

7,82

7,94

3,36

-1,39

-

Average direction of oscillations, degrees

-18,3

29,4

-10,0

46,4

12,6

-

CCP square, mm

82,8

50,1

73,5

28,9

-11,8

-

Quality of equilibrium function, %

83,3

20,3

85,3

11,3

2,00

-

Eyes-closed practice

 

 

 

 

 

 

CCP movement rate, mm/s

10,0

3,60

8,6

3,78

-1,36

-

Average direction of oscillations, degrees

7,57

47,4

8,12

38,8

0,60

-

CCP square, mm

134,2

39,3

112,4

108,3

31,2

-

Quality of equilibrium function, %

78,7

12,4

82,7

17,84

2,96

-

Romberg ratio, %

250,4

227,3

156,3

92,44

-40,1

-

Note: *difference was calculated net of the digits of indices (+ means increase, - means decrease);

PCFC - postural control function quality;

** significant difference with р ≤ 0.01.

Subjective ratings of the pain syndrome by the athletes and the postural balance control rates in the ballroom dancing movements were indicative of the pains being fully eliminated in the knee joints and thoracic section of the spine, with the pains in the lumbar section reported only accidentally and the postural balance quality being improved in most cases.

Conclusion. The summarized study data gives the means to put together the key principles of the focused and intensive biomechanical muscular activity on the trunk forms and orientations associated with the sport-specific postural disorders; and offer efficient corrective procedures in application to the male competitive ballroom dancers as subjects to the study. The most typical and significant rates of deviations from the physiological postural norms in the male competitive ballroom dancers are: moderately expressed scoliotic changes dominated by the left-side deviation in thoracic section with the right-side skew in pelvis; and moderately flattened lumbar lordosis with sub-normally limited front bending of pelvis. The postural disorders in the male dancers are due to the spine functionality being adapted to the training and competitive dancing positions and movements with the relevant imbalances in the trunk muscles being necessarily formed and progressed. The negative developments may include, among other things: asymmetric tonuses of muscular couples in the thoracic and lumbar spine sections (right hypertension with left stretching); and imbalances in the extensor/ flexor muscles (hypertension of the rectus abdominis muscles and stretching of the following muscles: musculus iliopsoas, square muscle, broad fascia and long extensor muscles of back). The above disorders are unsafe in the long run as they increase the risks of spondyloarthritis, spondylosis, compression of spinal cord and malfunctions of abdominal organs. As demonstrated by the study data, physical exercises dominated by the emphasized ellipsoid movements as a key element of the postural control training and involving the whole MSS in the preset positions with the subjective factors being minimized – help efficiently optimize the spatial positions of trunk and pelvis segments and rehabilitate the postural control abilities. The practices thereby help harmonize the supported dynamic workloads and overall metabolism and mitigate or eliminate the pain syndrome in the male competitive ballroom dancers. These study data give the reasons to find the corrective practices using the IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system being highly efficient as they ensure the trunk muscle tone and balance being harmonized on an integrated basis with the specific disorders being corrected. The method opens up new opportunities for unification of the MSS disorders prevention and rehabilitation methods on a time- and labour-efficient basis, the method being applicable in the athletic training process in different sport disciplines.

References

  1. Abramova T.F. Osobennosti prostranstvennogo polozheniya tulovishcha, taza i stop u vysokokvalifitsirovannykh sportsmenov muzhchin razlichnykh vidov sporta (Features of spatial position of torso, pelvis and feet in elite male athletes in different sports) / T.F. Abramova, T.M. Nikitina, N.I. Kochetkova, V.A. Krasnikov // Vestnik sportivnoy nauki. – 2013. –# 5. – P. 58-65.
  2. Abramova T.F. Labil'nye komponenty massy tela – kriterii obshchey fizicheskoy podgotovlennosti i kontrolya tekushchey i dolgovremennoy adaptatsii k trenirovochnym nagruzkam: metod. rekom. (Labile components of body weight - criteria for general conditioning level and control of current and long-term adaptation to training loads: method. recommendations) / T.F. Abramova, T.M. Nikitina, N.I. Kochetkova. – Moscow: Skyprint, 2013. – 132 p.
  3. Bunak V.V. Antropometriya (Anthropometry) / V.V. Bunak. – Moscow: MSU , 1941. – 376 p.
  4. Deryabin V.E. Mnogomernye biometricheskie metody dlya antropologov (Multidimensional biometric methods for anthropologists) / V.E. Deryabin, VINITI Dep. head # 37-V 2001, 10.01.2001. – 313 p.
  5. Myers Thomas W. Anatomicheskie poezda. Miofastsial'nye meridiany dlya manual'noy i sportivnoy meditsiny (Anatomy Trains. Myofascial Meridians for Manual and Movement Therapists) / Thomas W. Myers. – St. Petersburg: Publisher D.S. Merkulov, 2010. – 273 p.
  6. Mironova Z. S. Sportivnaya travmatologiya (Sport Traumatology) / Z.S. Mironova, E.M. Morozova. – Moscow: Sportivnye travmy. Klinicheskaya praktika preduprezhdeniya i lecheniya (Sport injuries. Clinical practice of prevention and treatment) / Ed. P.A.F. Kh. Renstrom. – Kiev: Olimpiyskaya literatura, 2003. – 470 p.
  7. Skvortsov D.V. Klinicheskiy analiz dvizheniy. Stabilometriya (Clinical analysis of movements. Stabilometry) / D.V. Skvortsov. – Moscow: Antidor, 2000. – 192 p.
  8. Starikov S.M. Fizicheskaya reabilitatsiya v kompleksnom lechenii bol'nykh s dorsopatiyami: monografiya RMAPO (Physical rehabilitation in complex treatment of patients with dorsopathy: monograph RMAPO) / S.M. Starikov, B.A. Polyaev, D.D. Bolotov. – 2nd ed. – Moscow: Krasnaya zvezda, 2012. –154 p.
  9. NORMES 85. – France: Paris, 1985.

Corresponding author: info@vniifk.ru

Abstract

Subject to the study were the postural disorders in trunk and pelvis and the relevant correction methods using an IMOOVE ELLIPS-M Training Simulator system in application to 18 competitive ballroom dancers of 16-26 years of age qualified from Class I Athletes to Masters of Sport and having formal competitive track records of 3 to 15 years. The study found a few most typical postural disorders in the subject male dancers, including: moderately expressed scoliotic changes dominated by the left-side thoracic disorders associated with the right-side skew in pelvis; and moderately flattened lumbar lordosis with sub-normally limited front bending of pelvis. It was further found that the process of the musculoskeletal system disorder prevention and correction by the training simulator is the most efficient when reasonably dominated by elliptical-round triple movements viewed as a basic motor sequence in the controlled motor practices designed to cause a consistent curative effect on the musculoskeletal system.